Everyday Pizza Dough

Everyday Pizza Dough

Sometimes the right thing to do is to let the recipe speak for itself…but hey, I’m Irish so I don’t have to let anyone or thing do the talking for me!

I plan on having many more pizza stories to share, especially now that Iron Phil and I have been deliberating, no, debating over what the right equipment, ingredients, temperature and so forth that make a perfect home baked pizza.

Pizza is a weird topic on its own.  I honestly think that one of the reasons people order it so much is that it is so much easier to have someone make it for us than to make it yourself. Look, I am sure price enters into the conversation too, after-all, it is hard to beat a $10 large pizza from Pizza Hut, or a $5 large one topping at Papa John’s. But let’s just say you LOVE pizza and you order the cool, hip, wood-fired, authentic, and every-other-snob-word pizza instead. What makes it good? Why do you keep coming back? Isn’t pizza just a basic bread dough recipe made of less than 5 ingredients? What gives then?

Grilled PIzza with Sausage, Mama Lil's Peppers, and fresh Basil
Grilled Pizza with Sausage, Mama Lil’s Peppers, and fresh Basil

Toppings are typically not the thing that holds people back, at least I don’t think. Although somewhat intimidating, buying pepperoni and mozzarella at the store seem easy enough, but lets just say you want to make a truly “Hawaiian” pizza at home, or better yet, a pizza that you absolutely LOVE at the local hipster pizzeria and you become a tad paralyzed with fear on how to actually pull it off! I mean, do you buy a pizza “sauce” or do you make it? Then your brain scrambles around to find that one odd fact that you swore someone told you that the peeps from Naples only use tomato sauce…thats it…nothing more. Oh wait…was it a specific tomato? I thought I wasn’t supposed to buy “out of season” tomatoes, no…that can’t be it…wait. Does it come from a jar? A can? Is that even OK? Oh *&%$ what do I do now? I am so confused!

So…we then order from our favorite local pizza chain or gangster independent and call it good. $17-25 later (plus tip, delivery charge, or if you eat there, a beer…), we had a great meal, but somehow still have that sinking feeling inside that we could, no, should make it at home.

Breakfast Pizza
Breakfast Pizza

I am here to help. I am here to sort through the questions and wade through the debates. I too, was “that guy” who decided for a long time, NOT to make pizza at home for all the reasons listed above and probably a dozen more. Until now…

It starts with the crust.

Whether you like thin crust or thick crust, it all starts here. Serious. I know what you are thinking. Cousin Leonardo has some old-world recipe that kills it every time. Or… “I heard that Trader Joe’s sells pretty good dough in the fridge section that ain’t half bad.”  Can I use that?  Well of course you can use your cousin’s recipe or buy it from Trader Joe’s or find a local pizza shop that is willing to sell you some dough (many will not)…

But wouldn’t it be that much cooler to your kids if YOU could be the guy who made the dough and put together consistently delicious pizzas for the family? Wouldn’t it be cool to be that dad or uncle?  If by some miracle, some chance, some cosmic alignment, you could…then you have the base for a future of consistently good, fun-to-make-with-the-kids, and even more fun to make pizza for every day.

Hey Look! The dough stores nicely for the freezer!
Hey Look! The dough stores nicely for the freezer!

The following recipe is from Jim Lahey, of the “no-knead” loaf of bread fame who made all kinds of dough famous at his NY Sullivan St Bakery.  Personally, I have tried all kinds of pizza dough’s. I have made them, bought them, and re-purposed them.  A shout out goes to the DALS blog gave me a ton of confidence on this one. This one, is consistent, utilitarian, and will make every one happy. Oh yeah, you can get two dough balls out of it, and it will keep in the freezer for that last minute meal!

Everyday Pizza Dough


  • 3 3/4 cups flour
  • 2 1/2 teaspoons instant or other active dry yeast
  • 3/4 teaspoon salt
  • 3/4 teaspoon sugar
  • 1 1/3 cup room-temperature water


  1. In a mixing bowl, stir together the flour, yeast, salt, and sugar. Add the water and, using a wooden spoon or your hand, mix until blended, with the paddle, at least 30 seconds (The dough will be stiff, not wet and sticky).
  2. Place dough hook and mix at medium speed for about 4-5 minutes or until the dough comes away from the bowl.
  3. Cover the bowl and let sit at room temperature until the dough has more than doubled in volume, about 2 hours.
  4. Divide the dough in two and shape each into flattened balls. (Dough can be frozen at this point.)
  5. When you are ready to make a pizza, preheat oven to 500°F roll out one ball of dough in a rectangular shape and place on an oiled cookie sheet. Top with your favorite toppings (make sure pork products have been pre cooked though!)

Related Posts

How to Sear and Bake a Steak

The great restaurants do it. The boys on the cooking shows do it…now its our turn. Step by step to perfect steak. How to Sear and Bake a Steak Step 1 Take the steak out of the refrigerator and bring to room temperature on a […]

Homemade “Artisan” Bread – Updated

Homemade “Artisan” Bread – Updated

I have decided to update this recipe simply because my “adult” children keep telling me that it isn’t clear. What do they know anyway…. It did get my attention though so I spent some time thinking about why and landed on the thought that my […]

3 thoughts on “Everyday Pizza Dough”

  • Do you have a blender? Here’s a slpime, delicious and very nutritious bread recipe. Potato Bread1 small potato (golf-ball-sized)1 c water1 c milk (warmed almost to boiling)1 tbsp (or 1 envelope) granulated yeast dissolved in 1/2 c warm water (water temp 110 degrees Fahrenheit)2 c oatmeal1/2 c brown sugar1/2 c whole wheat flour3 tbsp butter or oil1 tsp saltabout 6 cups flour, up to half can be whole wheat.Put the 2 c water in a small saucepan, peel and quarter the potato, add it to the water. Bring to a boil, simmer until potato is soft, about 15 mins. Pour potato and cooking water into blender container. Add hot milk to make two cups total of liquid, blender thoroughly. In a large bowl, add oats, brown sugar, salt, butter whole wheat flour to the hot milk/potato water mixture. Stir. Let sit 20 minutes.Stir in the yeast/water mixture.Beat in the flour 2 c at a time until the dough is not too sticky. Turn dough out onto a floured board and knead firmly for 10-15 minutes.Place dough in an oiled bowl, turning it so both sides are oiled. Cover with a clean towel. Let sit until risen almost double in size, about one hour. Punch down.Turn dough out onto a clean floured cutting board and knead until elastic and not sticky. Shape into rolls (about 12-15) and place on cookie sheet or divide dough into three parts and place in oiled loaf pans.Let rise again, about 1 hour.Bake loaves at 350 degrees for about 40 minutes. Bake rolls at 350 for 15-20 minutes.Brush tops with melted butter if desired.

  • love the blog! we have 5 children and would like more, so rdieang your blog is like a peek into what the future could be like! I’m wondering if you used molds to get those great shapes from the salt dough? and if so, WHERE did you find them? I’ve never seen any shaped like race cars or dinosaurs, just pretty ones for making candy.thanks!

Leave a Reply